How Businesses Should Respond to Section 44AB Audit-Related Notices

Getting an audit notice under Section 44AB can feel like a sudden emergency: confusing terms, tight timelines and the fear of penalties. You’re not alone—many salaried taxpayers, professionals, founders and MSMEs suddenly realise their books need to tell a clearer story to the tax officer.

Summary: If you get a Section 44AB notice, act fast: verify the notice, collect the right documents, reconcile AIS/26AS and TDS/TCS entries, consult a tax expert, and if needed, prepare for an audit or file a revised return. A structured response reduces penalties, speeds resolution and keeps your compliance record clean.

What’s the real problem in India?

Section 44AB requires certain taxpayers to get accounts audited by a Chartered Accountant. But the real challenge is the noise: AY/PY confusion, CBDT timelines, multiple notice formats, and mismatches between your books and the e-filing/AIS data. For small businesses and professionals, a first notice often highlights gaps rather than deliberate evasion. Understanding the forms, deadlines and how income tax india treats digital data is crucial.

• Symptom 1: You received a notice citing a different turnover figure than your books (often from TDS/TCS or AIS).
• Symptom 2: The notice deadline seems short and mentions audit reports or tax computation you don’t have ready.
• Symptom 3: Mismatch between ITR filed and AIS/26AS for a past year (maybe missed TDS/TCS entries).

What people get wrong

Common pitfalls escalate stress and penalties:

• Ignoring the notice or assuming it’s generic junk—never a good idea with CBDT communications.
• Panicking and sending half-baked documents—this often leads to follow-up notices or adverse assumptions.
• Treating AIS/26AS mismatches as trivial—TDS/TCS differences often trigger the whole issue.
• Thinking audit is only for large firms—thresholds change and professional incomes, presumptive schemes and capital gains indexation can pull you in.

A better approach

Responding properly is both tactical and procedural. Here’s a simple 4-step framework to follow:

1. Verify the notice: Confirm AY/PY, notice date, portal link and the specific grounds (turnover, presumptive income, or mismatch).
2. Reconcile records: Compare books, AIS/26AS, bank statements, TDS/TCS certificates and invoices. Identify the exact mismatch lines.
3. Engage a CA early: A Chartered Accountant prepares the audit opinion or a factual response, and negotiates procedural issues with the assessing officer.
4. Respond & document: File the reply on the e-filing portal, upload reconciliation schedules, and if audit is required, schedule the audit within the timeline.

Real-world example: A Bengaluru-based MSME received a Section 44AB notice citing higher turnover due to unclaimed TCS credits shown on AIS. A quick reconciliation revealed duplicate TCS credits from a supplier. The CA prepared a corrected statement and the issue was closed within six weeks—no penalty. Small fixes can save lakhs.

Quick implementation checklist

1. Open the notice immediately and note AY/PY, reference number and the portal link.
2. Download your AIS/26AS for the relevant AY from the e-filing portal.
3. Pull bank statements, sales register, purchase register and TDS/TCS certificates for the period.
4. Reconcile TDS/TCS: match each TDS entry in AIS/26AS to your Form 16B/Form 26QB/Form 16.
5. If turnover is cited, compute turnover under Section 44AB thresholds and check if presumptive scheme vs books is causing mismatch.
6. Contact your Chartered Accountant and share the notice + reconciliations within 3 working days.
7. Prepare a concise reply (facts + documents) and file on the e-filing portal; keep proof of upload.
8. If an audit is required, book the audit slot and gather ledgers, trial balance, and supporting vouchers.
9. Consider filing a revised return if errors led to the notice (mind the ITR filing last date and penalty implications).
10. Keep an audit trail of communications—emails, receipts, and portal acknowledgements—for future defence.

What success looks like

Measurable outcomes to expect after a systematic response:

• Lower or no penalty in the majority of cases where mismatches explain the notice.
• Faster closure of notice—weeks instead of months—when documentation is clear.
• Higher refund percentage or correct tax position after reconciling AIS/26AS and TDS/TCS entries.
• Reduced frequency of future notices due to improved bookkeeping and timely ITR revisions.
• Better banking and credit outcomes because financial statements are audit-ready.

Risks & how to manage them

Even with best efforts there are risks; manage them proactively:

• Risk: Penalties for non-compliance. Mitigation: Respond on time and obtain a CA opinion or representation.
• Risk: Adverse assessment due to missing invoices. Mitigation: Reconstruct records from bank, GST returns and supplier confirmations.
• Risk: Incorrect admission. Mitigation: Don’t admit facts without CA advice—responses can be used downstream.
• Risk: Multiple notices across years. Mitigation: Conduct a voluntary internal audit and file revised returns where justified.

Tools & data

Use these India-specific tools and data sources to speed response and avoid future notices:

• AIS/26AS from the Income Tax Department—your first source for TDS/TCS and reported credits.
• E-filing portal—download notices, file replies, and track status.
• TDS/TCS tracking tools and reconciliations in your accounting software (or Excel templates).
• Bank statements, GST returns, Form 26QB/16B/16—and capital gains indexation worksheets if sale of assets is involved.

FAQs

Q1: Who needs an audit under Section 44AB?
A: Businesses with turnover/sales above prescribed thresholds, and certain professionals with gross receipts above the limit. Thresholds change—confirm for the relevant AY. If in doubt, consult a CA.

Q2: What is the deadline to respond to a notice?
A: The notice itself states the timeline. Respond promptly on the e-filing portal. Also check ITR filing last date if the notice suggests a revision or late filing.

Q3: Can I ignore a mismatch shown in AIS/26AS?
A: No. AIS/26AS is a central record used by the department. Mismatches should be reconciled and corrected; often they are due to timing differences or unclaimed credits.

Q4: Will an audit always lead to extra tax or penalty?
A: Not necessarily. Many audits clarify records and close without additional tax if reconciliations explain the discrepancy—especially for MSMEs who cooperate and provide documentation.

Next steps

If you’ve received a Section 44AB notice, don’t delay. Start the reconciliation, gather your documents and speak with a Chartered Accountant. We help founders, professionals, salaried taxpayers and MSMEs prepare a calm, factual response that reduces risk and cost. For guidance on related matters—like claiming deductions under Section 80C limit, choosing between new vs old regime slabs, or ensuring TDS/TCS entries match your ITR—we can help.

Useful resources: [link:ITR guide] and [link:tax-saving tips] to get started on basic fixes and avoid repeat notices.

Work with Finstory. Speak with an Expert for a personalised plan to reduce your tax outgo and stay compliant. Book a free 20-min consultation.

---